Does God Regret?

regretThis is a question I’ve been asked a couple of times in the last couple of weeks. What does it mean when it says that God regretted or repented (eg. Gen 6:6 or 1 Sam 15:11). It’s not an easy question to answer succinctly but here’s what I normally say:

  1. Language – there are three ways you can talk about God: Univocal predication (God is literally a lion, or lamb); equivocal predication (God is nothing like a lion or a lamb); analogical predication (there is some quality we see in a lion which is maximally present in God). The first option would leave us with irreconcilable contradictions; the second option would leave us with nothing meaningful to say; the third option properly describes how language works when talking about the attributes and actions of God.
  2. Accommodation – since God is infinite and eternal when he reveals himself to us he has to accommodate that revelation to our finite understanding. We could never comprehend the full wonder of his infinite being. He speaks truly but not exhaustively, as do we.
  3. Because God is infinite that is true also of his emotions or passions. God is maximally alive and his passions are perfect and eternal. He doesn’t chuck a strop or get excited about chocolate like we do. It’s important to realise that God is not a really big super strong man. Eternality and infinitude are not finitude and temporality extended really really big – they are a different mode of existence. This is why it’s hard for us to fully understand some of this stuff. We know truly but not exhaustively.
  4. So, when we talk about God regretting or repenting we speak truly but not exhaustively. We speak analogically not univocally. He accommodates the revelation of himself to us. His passions are perfect, maximal, and eternal. If you want to meditate on something that’s perhaps more edifying think about this. Is God grieved over sinners? Yes, maximally and eternally – far more than we could ever comprehend. Does God rejoice over saints? Yes, maximally, perfectly, eternally – far more than you or I could ever begin to comprehend. Far from being intellectual, cold, or sterile, this stuff should move our hearts as we meditate upon his greatness.

Anything else you’d add or I’ve missed?


3 Replies to “Does God Regret?”

  1. Salts,

    That’s a great framework to help us think about the question but is that really what you normally SAY?

    I mean, do you ever get to finish your first sentence about univocal predication, equivocal predication and analogical predication before they pour their coffee on your head?

    so what do you say? how do you/we ‘accommodate’ those concepts in simpler language?

    1. haha – actually I do say something like this depending on who I’m talking to. So chatting with our apprentice a couple of weeks back i did introduce those terms (and explain them) and he found it helpful. If I’m talking to someone in the youth group I suppose I’m more like to use phrases like ‘exactly like’ (univocal); ‘nothing like’ (equivocal); something like (analogical). Does that help – have I accommodated well enough to your simple mind? 😉

  2. The order of how we say things can help too. I’d be tempted with quite a few people to go straight in for the point 4 stuff …what is the point being made in the Bible? Well God cares very much about what goes on in his World. He isn’t disinterested…distant …..does that mean he changes his mind? No. So shall we talk about how that works. What words/phrases does the Bible use to describe God ….does that mean he has actual arms/legs …?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s